Checklist of strategies to ensure rigour in the conduct and reporting of the study
Research step | Criteria | Action taken |
Quantitative component | Dependability | Data collection will be conducted using standardised scripts. |
Credibility and confirmability | Reflexive notes will be taken during data collection to record situational information. | |
Confirmability | Reasons for non-participation will be noted. | |
Confirmability | All statistical analyses will be performed according to a prespecified protocol. | |
Qualitative component | Dependability | Data collection will be conducted used standardised scripts. |
Confirmability | Reasons for loss to follow-up will be noted. | |
Credibility and confirmability | Reflexive notes will be taken during data collection to record situational information. | |
Dependability | A sample of the transcripts (eg, 10%) from each site will be checked against the audio recordings. | |
Credibility | More than one person will be involved in the analysis of interview data. | |
Credibility | Persons involved in the analysis of interview transcripts will look for disconfirming data while developing themes to ensure that all aspects of the interviews were considered. | |
Dependability | An investigator with proficiency in English and Spanish will compare the English and Spanish findings. | |
Mixed methods component | Credibility | The justification for using a mixed methods approach to answer the research question(s) will be described. |
Credibility | The study design will be described in terms of the purpose, priority and sequence of methods. | |
Credibility | The process of integration will be described in terms of where it occurred, how it occurred and who participated in it. | |
Credibility | The limitation of one method associated with the presence of the other method will be described. | |
Credibility | Insights gained from mixing or integrating methods will be described. | |
Credibility | The integration of quantitative and qualitative research methods will occur at multiple points of the mixed methods study (eg, research question, sampling strategy and analysis). | |
Confirmability and dependability | Each data source will be triangulated to confirm convergence or divergence across datasets and study sites. | |
Credibility | Inconsistencies between quantitative and qualitative findings will be explored. | |
Credibility | The inferences derived from the quantitative and qualitative findings will be incorporated into meta-inferences. | |
Entire study | Confirmability | An audit trail will be maintained by the research coordinator to document all study decisions (and their rationale) and all sampling, data collection and analysis procedures implemented. |
Confirmability | Any deviations from the published protocol will be noted and justified to promote transparency of the research methods. |